Head to head

The honest comparison.

Feature✓ Aluminium boatsFibreglass boats
Impact resistanceExcellent — dents not cracks. Weldable.More vulnerable to cracks, chips and osmosis
MaintenanceLow — no gelcoat, no osmosis treatmentHigher — gelcoat maintenance, osmosis checks
WeightGenerally lighter — better for traileringGenerally heavier for equivalent size
RepairabilityEasy — any welder can repair hull damageRequires specialist fibreglass/gelcoat work
Beaching & slipwaysWell suited — handles rough launchesMore care needed — gelcoat chips easily
Lifespan40–50+ years with proper care20–30 years typically before major work
PriceBetter value — lower cost than premium brandsJeanneau, Arvor, Quicksilver, Merry Fisher cost more
Luxury feelFunctional and practical — working characterOften more polished interior finish
Ride qualityFirm — some prefer the direct feelOften slightly quieter and softer
Best forFishing, working, harsh coastal & commercialLeisure cruising, comfort-focused weekend use
Impact resistance
✓ Aluminium
Dents not cracks. Weldable.
Fibreglass
More vulnerable to cracks & osmosis
Maintenance
✓ Aluminium
No gelcoat, no osmosis
Fibreglass
Regular gelcoat maintenance needed
Weight
✓ Aluminium
Generally lighter
Fibreglass
Generally heavier
Repairability
✓ Aluminium
Any welder can repair
Fibreglass
Specialist work required
Beaching & slipways
✓ Aluminium
Handles rough launches
Fibreglass
More care needed
Lifespan
✓ Aluminium
40–50+ years
Fibreglass
20–30 years typically
Price
✓ Aluminium
Better value
Fibreglass
Premium brands cost more
Best for
✓ Aluminium
Fishing, working, coastal
Fibreglass
Leisure cruising, comfort
Our honest verdict: If you want a polished weekend cruiser, fibreglass may still suit you. If you want a practical, tough fishing boat built for real UK conditions — where you'll beach it, work it hard and expect it to last decades without constant maintenance — aluminium is the smarter choice.
Value comparison

What does your money buy?

The TH750 Big Cabin starts from £30,000 + VAT. Here's how that compares to established fibreglass alternatives of similar size.

TH750 Big Cabin (All Heart Marine)
From £30,000 + VAT

7.5m aluminium hull. 5mm bottom plate. Enclosed cabin with proper door. Fish tanks, rod holders. Diesel heater option. Factory-direct pricing.

Comparable fibreglass wheelhouse
Typically £40,000–£70,000+

Equivalent fibreglass wheelhouse cabin boats from established brands typically start considerably higher. Higher ongoing gelcoat maintenance costs.

Long-term ownership costs
Aluminium typically lower

No osmosis treatment, no gelcoat repairs, no hull polishing over 40+ years. Aluminium long-term maintenance costs are significantly lower than fibreglass equivalents.

FAQ

Common comparison questions.

Is aluminium or fibreglass better for sea fishing UK?
For practical sea fishing in UK conditions — launching from slipways, beaching, handling rough water and working the boat hard — aluminium offers significant advantages. Impact resistance, lower maintenance and longer lifespan make it the preferred choice for serious anglers and commercial operators.
Do aluminium fishing boats rust?
Marine-grade aluminium alloy 5083-H116 does not rust. It forms a natural oxide layer that protects it from corrosion. Sacrificial anodes should be fitted and replaced regularly to protect against galvanic corrosion in saltwater — the same requirement as any metal boat.
Is a fibreglass boat quieter than aluminium?
Fibreglass hulls typically produce slightly less hull noise than aluminium at speed. This is one area where fibreglass has a genuine advantage. For most anglers and commercial users this is a minor consideration compared to the practical advantages of aluminium.
Can I insure an aluminium boat the same as fibreglass?
Yes. Aluminium boats are insured through standard UK marine insurers in exactly the same way as fibreglass boats. Insurance companies are familiar with aluminium hulls.

Ready to choose aluminium?

View our boats, request a spec sheet or book a sea trial from Portsmouth.

View TH750 Big Cabin Request a quote